Yadot Nedarim, R. Joseph Saul Nathanson, Lemberg 1851 (50774)

יד יוסף ויד שאול, ידות נדרים - Only Edition

Current Price: Virtual Judaica will bid incrementally for you up to your maximum bid. Your maximum bid is kept a secret from other users.

Your bid is a contract between you and the listing creator. If you have the highest bid you will enter into a legally binding purchase contract.

Minimum Bid:  ( + )
Your Maximum Proxy Bid: $ USD

Your Listing Options

for more options
Status: Active Remaining Time: 17 Hours, 36 Minutes
Current Bid:  
Reserve Price Met  
Auction Ends: Tuesday, April 13, 2021 11:30:30 AM
Bid History: 1 Bids  
Page Views: 37  

Listing Details

Lot Number: 50774
Title (English): Yadot Nedarim
Title (Hebrew): יד יוסף ויד שאול, ידות נדרים
Note: First Edition
Author: R. Joseph Saul Nathanson
City: Lemberg
Publisher: דפוס פנחס משה באלאבאן
Publication Date: 1851
Estimated Price: $200.00 USD - $500.00 USD
Content/listingImages/20210320/50774-0_fullsize.jpg Content/listingImages/20210320/50774-1_fullsize.jpg


Physical Description

Only edition. [2], 64; [1], 7 ff., folio, 391:214 mm., wide margins, light age staining. A very good copy bound in later boards.

Detail Description

Novellae to Yore De'ah laws of Nedarim (vows) by R. Joseph Saul Nathanson (1810–1875). He was born in Berezhany, the son of R. Aryeh Leibush Nathanson of Brody, a wealthy businessman who was also a profound talmudist. In 1825 he married Sarah Idel, the daughter of R. Isaac Aaron Ettinger, who was also a great scholar and a wealthy man. R. Nathanson, as was customary in those days, was maintained in his father-in-law's home. When his father-in-law died shortly after his marriage, his mother-in-law administered the business and took care that he would be able to live and study without financial cares, and when she died in 1841, his wife took over the responsibility. In his father-in-law's house R. Nathanson found a colleague in his brother-in-law, R. Mordecai Ze'ev Ettinger. They studied together for several years and compiled a series of halakhic works, but they separated as a result of a difference of opinion which came to a head on the question of the permissibility of machine-baked mazzot. The two brothers-in-law were rival candidates for the rabbinate of Lemberg to which R. Nathanson was appointed in 1857. The same year his wife died, but in 1858 he married a wealthy woman and did not accept a salary.

R. Nathanson was the outstanding posek and writer of responsa of his generation. Problems reached him from all parts of the world and he corresponded with all the great contemporary scholars. In his works he is revealed principally as an instructor in practical halakhah. He regarded himself as responsible for the condition of halakhah in his time, in succession to such scholars as R. Akiva Eger and R. Moses Sofer. He was opposed to the method of pilpul for its own sake, regarding it as suitable only for youths (Divrei Sha'ul, Aggadot, 29b) but not for those destined to be religious teachers. He did not necessarily base his decision "upon the statements of aharonim" (Sho'el u-Meshiv, 2 pt. 3, no. 108), but based his rulings mainly upon the Talmud and the rishonim. He tended to leniency in his rulings, and took contemporary circumstances into consideration. He was one of those who permitted machine-baked mazzot in opposition to the view of R. Solomon Kluger. Although R. Kluger decided that etrogim from Corfu were invalid because of the fear that they were hybrids, R. Nathanson permitted them (Yosef Da'at, Kilei Begadim, no. 302). He also regarded the birds called "kibbitzer" hens as permitted according to the dietary laws although other authorities forbade them (Sho'el u-Meshiv, 3 pt. 2, no. 121). Although known for his permissive approach, however, he sometimes declared things forbidden simply as a precaution (Yosef Da'at, Terefot, 64–65). It was this which prompted R. Dov Berush Meisels, rabbi of Warsaw, to say of him: "I know him of old as one who adopts a stringent and not a lenient line" (end of the pamphlet Moda'ah le-Veit Yisrael). Despite his leniency in halakhic ruling, he fought with all his power against the progressives in his community who wanted to introduce reforms into education. When the government sought to compel the Jews of Galicia to send their children to government schools and to bar them from the heder until they had passed four classes of the secular schools, as well as to make the teachers pass an examination in German and pedagogy, R. Nathanson took the initiative in uniting the great talmudic scholars to obtain the repeal of the edict (see R. S. Kluger's letter of 1867 in Toledot Shelomo (1956), 113ff.).


Hebrew Description

 ... אשר חברתי... יוסף שאול הלוי (נאטינזאהן)... חלק א-ב.

חלק א: על הלכות נדרים [עם הפנים]... בשם ידות נדרים. [2], סד דף.

חלק ב: יד שאול... מהלכות שבועות עד כלות הלכות חדש. [1], עג דף.



Bibliography of the Hebrew Book 1470-1960 #000162090; EJ