× Bidding has ended on this item.

Avnei Millu'im, R. Aryeh Leib ha-Kohen Heller, Halberstadt 1860

אבני מלואים

Listing Image
  • Lot Number 51331
  • Title (English) Avnei Millu'im
  • Title (Hebrew) אבני מלואים
  • Author R. Aryeh Leib ben Joseph ha-Kohen Heller
  • City Halberstadt
  • Publisher (J. Hoerling’s Wittwe)
  • Publication Date 1860
  • Estimated Price - Low 200
  • Estimated Price - High 500

  • Item # 1920486
  • End Date
  • Start Date

Physical Description

[2], 75 [i.e. 85], X; [1], 77, 29, [1] ff., folio, 328:202 mm., age and damp staining, nice margins. A good copy bound in later boards, rubbed.

Detail Description

Avnei Millu'im Part I-II by R. Aryeh Leib ben Joseph ha-Kohen Heller (1745?–1813), Galician rabbi, a descendant of R. Yom Tov Lipmann Heller. Heller was born in Kalisz, and studied under R. Meshullam Igra of Pressburg. In his youth he served as rabbi of the small town of Rozhnyatov, Galicia, where he lived in poverty, and there he wrote his works. He went from there to Lemberg where he was a teacher of Talmud. The publication of his Kezot ha-Hoshen brought him fame, and in 1788 he was elected rabbi of Stry (Pol. Stryi), where he established a large yeshivah. Stry was a center of Hasidism, and although Heller violently opposed the Hasidim, the hasidic rabbis themselves held him in great esteem and referred to him as a "prince of the Torah." The dayyan R. David ha-Kohen attacked him and even published a work Ahavat David vi-Yhonatan in criticism of the Kezot ha-Hoshen but the work had no repercussions. Kezot ha-Hoshen (2 pts., Lemberg, 1788–96), on the Shulhan Arukh, Hoshen Mishpat, was acclaimed by scholars and students of yeshivot with unusual enthusiasm as soon as it appeared and to the present day is regarded as a classic work of halakhic pilpul. R. Jacob Lorbeerbaum, one of the important posekim of his generation, devoted a considerable portion of his Netivot ha-Mishpat (Zolkiew, 1809–16) to a polemic with R. Heller. R. Heller replied to the criticisms in a special work, Meshovev Netivot. R. Heller died before he completed the work, which covers only chapters 1–133 of the Hoshen Mishpat. As a result of this profound work R. Lorberbaum made considerable changes and additions to his work, even though he does not mention the name of his opponent. Beside R. Lorberbaum many other well-known contemporary rabbis discussed the Kezot in their own works, which in itself is an unusual phenomenon. R. Heller's other works were also enthusiastically received by scholars: Avnei Millu'im (Lemberg, 1816) on the Shulhan Arukh, Even ha-Ezer, and the Shev Shemateta (ibid., 1804), an examination and clarification of the laws concerning cases which involve doubt. All his works have gone through many editions and all still serve as a cornerstone of the method of Torah learning in the yeshivot, despite the radical changes in method effected in the Lithuanian yeshivot by R. Hayyim Soloveichik. These three works may therefore be regarded as classics in the accepted sense of the word. It is worthy of note that his method of study gained adherents both in Poland and Lithuania despite the difference in method in both places. The Kezot combines great acumen with logical reasoning, and is distinguished by its scintillating analysis, and its emphasis on the inner logic of the halakhah. Specially worthy of note are the introductions which R. Heller wrote to his works, particularly that to his Shev Shematata. It freely combines sound logic, extensive erudition, and a profound acumen in its explanation of aggadic topics and ideas and morals. His brother Judah Heller appended to the Kezot ha-Hoshen his Kunteres ha-Sefekot.

Hebrew Description

דף פב: חידושים מאת ר’ יוסף דוב בעריש (דודו של המחבר) בהלכות קידושין.


Bibliography of the Hebrew Book 1470-1960 #000127210; EJ; A. Stern, Melizei Esh al Hodshei Tishri u-Marheshvan (1933), 95b, no. 235; H. Tchernowitz, Toledot ha-Posekim, 3 (1947), 246–52; J. A. Kamelhar, Dor De'ah (1953), 126–9.